Ice Cream at the Headstone

Prefer to listen? This essay is read aloud on Spotify and YouTube.

I want to slow down for this one.

There are a few things in a life the world rushes you past, and grief is the one it rushes you past hardest. So this will move slower, and it will ask more of your time, not because there is more to say, but because this is the one thing that should be sat with rather than solved. If you have lost someone, you were given about two weeks to feel it before the world expected you back. I am not going to do that to you here.

Some losses leave a mark you have never been able to look at straight. A piece taken out of you that never quite finds a connection to your life again, that changed the shape of you, and that you learned to carry without ever really describing. Every family and every faith has its own way of marking a death, and I am not going to step on any of them, because what I want to say sits underneath all of them. I only ask that you let this take the time it asks for. I will start with my own, because I will not send you anywhere I have not stood.

I was lying on my couch, half the country away from the small town I grew up in, with no way to get to him at two in the morning, waiting to hear that my father had pulled through a surgery that was urgent but, everyone assured me, routine. I knew full well he would. It felt wrong to sleep in the comfort of my own bed while he was on a table, so I stayed on the couch. A message came that the surgery seemed to have gone well and they would update me soon. Then nothing came. When the phone finally rang it was my mom, and I was dazed, and my first feeling was guilt, that I might actually have fallen asleep and the call was waking me.

I answered ready for the good news. What came instead was almost nothing. A faint sobbing under the silence, so quiet it was barely noticeable. I said hello. I heard her swift, choked breath trying to recover from the tears, and then she said it. He did not make it.

I sat up quickly and felt my skin peel off the leather couch like a Band-Aid that had been left on far too long. The words landed in much the same way, abrupt and painful. My response was short, and angry, and confused. What. To this day I do not know whether it was confusion or an escalating anger with no patience for what could only be a joke in unspeakably poor taste, my coping already deep in denial. He was just going in for a routine surgery, and now you are telling me he is gone. That is incomprehensible. There is no way to reconcile this information.

I sat there after the call. Quiet. Waiting for the tears to become a downpour, but they did not. They only trickled, like a soft rain down my cheeks, my brow still furrowed. I looked over at the phone on the coffee table and did a double take at it, turning over the possibility that this was a lucid dream I was letting play out of some grim curiosity, despite the pain. In what I can only describe as delirium, I picked the phone up and called my girlfriend, who was waiting with the same certainty I had that the news would be good. She picked up, and I could hear the deep anxiousness in her hello, almost echoing my own. And as I let the first words of the sentence begin to form, the downpour finally came, as though it had been looming the whole time, waiting for this exact moment. Two simple words. Dad died. The reality formed fiercely and with no mercy. The crash of it was an impact with no audio, just a ringing in the ears and her voice reaching me through it, a breathless, heavily gasped oh my god that only deepened the whole visceral weight of it.

And this is the part I did not understand until long after. The reality became firmer in the telling than it had in the hearing. Hearing the words, I could hold at arm's length, turn into a bad dream, refuse. But forming the sentence myself, giving it my own voice, put me into contact with the thing in a way that receiving someone else's words never had. That is worth knowing, and I will come back to it, because the same act that broke me open turns out to be part of how you carry them afterward.

Maybe your news came in a different shape. Maybe there was no call at all, only a room and a machine, or a long illness that ended just as you were warned and ambushed you anyway. It does not matter. If you have gotten the news that someone woven into the structure of your life is gone, you know the body agrees to it before the mind will. And you may know the other thing too, that at some point in those first hours you had to say it out loud to somebody, and that saying it may have been worse, and truer, than hearing it had been.

Then the world does the one merciful thing it knows how to do. It gathers. Whatever your people do, they do it now. The traditions give you time away from the mundane, the ordinary responsibilities held off for a little while, and everyone comes close. For a week, maybe two, the loss is out in the open where it can be shared, and there is a strange and real sweetness pressed up against the grief, an intoxicating kind of gratitude and an intimate connection in the sorrow carried together. This is what ritual is for. Underneath their differences, many traditions do some version of the same work. They gather people around the fact of a death so that no one has to stand next to it entirely alone.

And then, because it is built to, it ends. Everyone goes back to lives that did not stop the way yours did. The tradition did its job. It honored the death. But nothing was ever built to honor the third month, or the second year. And that is where the grief no one warned you about actually begins.

You go back, because you have to. And the mundane that had the decency to pause comes back all at once. The work you left unattended is still there, and now there is more of it, the laundry overflowing the basket, the messages stacked, the ordinary machinery of a life that kept running while yours stopped. At first the people around you are careful, and then, slowly, they are not, because the ones who rely on you have their own demands, and those pile back up just the same, and the world's memory for someone else's loss is short. Your loss goes unnoticed. And in that gap, between how wrecked you actually are and how recovered you are expected to look, something starts to turn.

I will tell you how it turned in me, and you can decide if you know it. The anger and the frustration started to mix into something toxic. I began to see everyone as selfish, entitled, like toddlers waiting to be served my time and my attention, oblivious, when I had just suffered an unfathomable loss that had taken a piece out of me that would never find a connection to my life again. How selfish, I thought. How entitled can people be. It was the exact opposite of those first days, of the intoxicating closeness of shared sorrow. Now everyone seemed disconnected from the reality of loss, so far from it that they could carry on through an unimpressive routine of their day as if nothing had happened. Grief's shape is not uniform. It shifts with every new experience you have since the day they leave you. Everything is new. You are born again, only now with the terrible new context of how fragile life is, how finite, while everyone around you stays veiled in the delusion of a copious supply of time, spending their lives on trivial tasks, in trivial lives.

I have to stop and be honest about that stretch, because it felt like clarity and it was not. It was a jaded period sculpted by a nihilistic hand, and that hand tightens its grip by convincing you that your loss has made you see truer than everyone else. Part of it is true. Loss does hand you a real and permanent knowledge of how finite this is. But the contempt stitched onto that truth is a lie. Those people are not entitled. They are not asleep out of some failure of character. They are exactly what you were the day before your own call. Innocent. Still inside the ordinary belief that there is plenty of time. Or, just as likely, not innocent at all, but quietly carrying a loss of their own behind a face you are reading no better than they are reading yours. What feels like their selfishness is really your own isolation, the loneliness of carrying knowledge into a room where you have assumed no one else has had to learn it yet. And staying in the anger, I would come to see, was the one thing in that whole situation that was actually mine, and I was spending it as badly as the people I was judging.

I lost the nihilism when I started spending more time with his memory. It did not happen all at once, and I will not pretend it never returns, because it does, in smaller waves, on the harder days. But it lifted, and it lifted because of a question I finally had to put to myself. I could not change what had happened. That was never mine to change. But the anger I kept carrying at a situation entirely out of my control: was I, without quite meaning to, choosing to keep feeding it? I do not put that to you as an accusation. I put it only the way I had to put it to myself, as an honest question. You do not choose the grief. But there may be a part of the aftermath you have some quiet say over, and it can be worth asking, gently, which part that is.

The first time we really felt how much he would have loved something was the day we spread his ashes, at one of his favorite spots out in nature. As we were spreading them, a bald eagle showed up and circled the area. A bald eagle is a rare sighting in this part of the world, and it was one of his favorite animals. It felt as if he was there with us, and if he was not, then his memory was. I am not going to tell you which it was. I do not know. What I know is that standing there, the difference between the two stopped mattering as much as I had always assumed it would.

Because that was the beginning of the thing that changed everything. I had believed, without ever once checking the belief, that death had closed the account, that all I had left of him was a fixed pile of the past to be rationed and reread until it wore thin. It is not true. One of the things we still do, even now, is make new memories with him. When I go home, we visit his grave, and we bring ice cream, because taking my daughter for ice cream was something he had been looking forward to and never got the chance to do. So we do it now. She is making memories with a grandfather she barely got to meet, and they are real, because I am there to carry his half of them.

It was a warm feeling, and a settling one, to realize that he was physically gone but the chance to make memories with his memory was not. A part of my life was missing, and yet it had not vanished. It had reformed in the same place, changed from something physical into something I carry, memory and emotion and the small daily habit of him, and that, it turns out, is where so much of what mattered most between us had lived all along. It did not end. It changed form. And you still feel it.

And here is the quiet thing I most want to hand you. Somewhere in grief there is a belief that the pain is how you stay loyal, that to hurt less would be to love less, that your suffering is the proof the love was real. I do not think that is true. And I do not believe your ongoing pain is the memorial the person you lost would want you to build. Mine used to say a thing to me, plainly, more than once.

Do not be like me. Be better than me.

It took losing him to understand that honoring him could not mean lying down in the wreckage. It had to mean getting up and doing the thing he had asked of me.

I know the days this finds you hardest, because they are the same for most of us. The birthdays. The anniversary of the day they died. Christmas, Mother's Day or Father's Day if one of them applies to you, the holidays most of all, because so often the person you lost was a big part of those days, the one who led them, and their absence is felt deepest exactly where their presence used to loom largest. And it is not only the days. It is the places too, the spots that held something with them, that can empty you out the moment you walk back into them. Those are the times grief comes back at full strength, and they are, cruelly, the same times the world has quietly decided you should be over it by now. No one checks in on the person still grieving a year on, or three, because from the outside you look like you healed. You went back to work. You laugh again. You seem fine. So the still-grieving grieve in private, on the marked days, behind a face no one is reading. If that is you, let this be the thing that does not look away. Consider this me, checking in on you, on the day you were sure no one remembered was hard. It is still as heavy as it is. You did not fail to get over it. There was never anything to get over. There was only something to learn to carry, and then to learn to carry differently.

One honest thing before the last of it, because I will not pretend from here that every loss fits what I have described. Some grief is heavier than any turning-toward can lift, and sits far past the point where a memory is medicine. And some losses cannot yet do what I am describing at all. The loss of a child. The sudden and violent kind. The death tangled up in things that were never gentle, where there is no memory clean enough to carry forward, at least not now. If that is nearer to where you are, hear me carefully. Nothing I have written is a substitute for real help, and letting someone qualified sit with you in it is not weakness. It may be the strongest and most loving thing you do for the life you still have to live. I would not insult your loss by pretending this could be that for you.

And for the rest of us, on the ordinary marked days, this is where I have to step back, because I cannot do the part that matters. I cannot do your grieving for you. I cannot be the one who checks in every year when the date comes around, and one essay cannot sit beside you on every hard morning. So do not let it end here, moved for an afternoon and back under the weight by dark.

You do not have to stop making memories with their memory. It has been one of the most important things I have done, and it is far more than it sounds. Say it out loud when they would have loved something. Ask what they would do, what their advice would be, and listen for the answer you already carry. Take the ice cream to the grave. Bring them into the life they do not get to see, so that the people who never met them somehow still do. And carry your own version of the thing my father gave me. Do not be like me, be better than me was his. Yours will be its own. Find it, and go be it.

You are not done making memories with them. You only thought you were. Death takes the person. It does not have to take the relationship. That part can still be yours to keep.

For my father.